Back to SearchPodcastsI Think Not!
Podcasts
I Think Not!
@ithinknotTracked since May 2026
Observed Jul 22, 2026 · staleModeled revenue
Creating bonus podcast episodes and extra fun!.
How Patreon Signal reads this profile
Identity, tiers, posts, and visible counts come from the latest public Patreon observation. Growth compares available public snapshots. Revenue is labeled observed only when Patreon exposes it; otherwise it is modeled from public membership and tier signals.
Paid members
9,684
4% · 30 days
Total audience
18,132
incl. free followers
Estimated monthly gross
$96.8K
$48.4K–$145.3K modeled range
Starting price
$5/mo
6 membership tiers
Membership tiers
Pricing and benefits captured publicly
Patreon is not exposing patron counts by tier for this creator, so this section shows public prices and benefits only.
$0/moFreePublic prices and benefits only
$5/moDown BitchHey, Down Bitches! Each month, you get 3 bonus episodes covering a true crime series (that you get to help select!) and an additional bonus episode covering a fun, true crime adjacent show! Four bonus episodes of hilarity each month!
$10/moBreckenridge BestieIn addition to the bonus episodes and monthly specials, the Breckenridge Besties also have access to ad-free regular episodes and are part of our Close Friends circle on the Insta!
$15/moHallelujah! Whatsittoya?In addition to all of the benefits of the other tiers, the members of Hallelujah! Whatsittoya? also have access to monthly live watch parties with Ellyn and Joey, one bonus episode hangout where Joey and Ellyn discuss hot topics, pop culture & AMAs, as well as access to the I Think Not! Discord server
$20/moTake a Sprite and LeaveIn addition to all of the benefits of the other tiers, the members of Take a Sprite and Leave will have access to monthly live Swamp Talk recordings, as well as a quarterly Sip 'n Paint experience! You must be a member for 3 consecutive months to receive the Sip 'n Paint experience. More about the Sip ‘n Paint Experience here:Join us for our first Art Therapy, an arty party over zoom! Let’s trauma bond and paint Somebody’s Watching Me inspired by the nightmare fuel that is Phrogging. No experience needed; I, Katie, EichenPaint, Eichenberger, paint along with you step by step. Am I a therapist? Sure…as much as Ellyn is a lawyer. Look, it’s less about making a masterpiece, and more about being weirdos and having a good gigglefest. Grab your brush and apron down your tits: it’s about to get really messy.
$30/moFahts not Dahts**New sign ups will open on 5/1In addition to all of the benefits of the other tiers, the members of Fahts not Dahts will receive exclusive merchandise. You must be a member for 3 consecutive months to receive the merch. This will be 1-2 accessory type items like a coloring book, shipping in a polymailer. They are pre-chosen and sent in a surprise box! Merch retail value will equal or exceed $30. US shipping is included, extra international shipping rates may apply.
Growth signals — I Think Not!
+4%
Membership9,684 paid members · past 30 days
9.7K9.5K9.3K
May 202614 weeks trackedNow
I Think Not!9.7K members · $96.8K/mo
The chart only uses I Think Not!'s observed public history. Comparison peers are listed below, but comparable trend series are not available yet.
Creator comparisons
5 creators shownWhere I Think Not! ranks
Compare within
#18 of 9 cohort creators measured
Estimated gross in Recommended cohort
A focused cohort chosen from content relevance, category, audience, pricing, and cadence. Changing the rank metric does not change who belongs in this cohort.
8 of 9 cohort creators have a usable estimated gross; the other 1 remains unranked for this metric.Ranking data · includes stale rows| Rank | Creator and why included | Estimated gross | Gap vs I Think Not! | Freshness |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | I Think Not!ProfilePodcastsEstimated gross position in Recommended cohort | $96.8K | Reference | Jul 22, 2026Stale |
| #2 |  SinisterhoodPodcastsContent relevance + business context | $22.5K | $74.3K fewer | Aug 4, 2026 |
| #3 |  This Feels Criminal | Formerly Killer QueensPodcastsContent relevance + business context | $11.3K | $85.6K fewer | Aug 3, 2026 |
| #4 |  True Crime & CocktailsPodcastsContent relevance + business context | $4.8K | $92.1K fewer | Aug 5, 2026 |
| #5 |  Going West True CrimePodcastsContent relevance + business context | $2.3K | $94.5K fewer | Aug 4, 2026 |
The rank uses the full fixed cohort. This table shows up to five creators around I Think Not!; the coverage summary above still counts everyone.
What they publish
Recent posts
1,046Profile posts7 postsLast month100%Members-only
Previews available for 44 of 1,046 posts
Article Latest post$5 tier & upVacation This Week from Weds Episode!6 hours ago
6 hours ago 34 likes 8 commentsRUNDOWN LINK!4 days agoArticle4 days ago at Jul 22 crawl$5 tier & up 8 1SPONSOR CODES! you don't hear!5 days agoArticle5 days ago at Jul 22 crawl$5 tier & up 40 12Rundown Recording Tomorrow!5 days agoArticle5 days ago at Jul 22 crawl$5 tier & up 21 1I Think Not Patreon FeedMurder in Glitterball City - Episode 1 July 16ArticleJuly 16$5 tier & up 62 35I Think Not Patreon FeedAD-FREE: Unsolved Mysteries - Season 6, Episode 1 July 15ArticleJuly 15$5 tier & up 33 25Rundown Not Live this Week!July 9ArticleJuly 9$5 tier & up 34 17I Think Not Patreon FeedMaternal Instinct - Part 2 July 9ArticleJuly 9$5 tier & up 90 58I Think Not Patreon FeedAD-FREE: Worst Ex Ever - Ride or Die (S2E4) July 8ArticleJuly 8$5 tier & up 35 16I Think Not Patreon FeedSwamp Talk July! July 6ArticleJuly 6$5 tier & up 21 11AMERICA'S RUNDOWNJuly 4ArticleJuly 4$5 tier & up 15 20LIVE RECORDING!July 3ArticleJuly 3$5 tier & up 23 4
Continue your research
Keep I Think Not! in context.
Save the creator, add them to a comparison, or return to the exact Explore view you came from.