Writing
Justine Smith
@carnaleyeTracked since May 2026
creating Film Criticism and Writing.
Observed Aug 26, 2026 · staleModeled revenue
Paid members
2
0% · 30-day rate from 24 observed days
Total audience
7
incl. free followers
Estimated monthly gross
$4
$2–$6 modeled range
Starting price
$1/mo
6 membership tiers
Pricing and benefits captured publicly
Membership tiersPatreon is not exposing patron counts by tier for this creator, so this section shows public prices and benefits only.
$0/moFreePublic prices and benefits only
$1/moFriendIf you want to support my work in a more general way, this is the way to go. If you love my tweets, my Letterboxd lists, and want to help out a little bit this is the way to go.
$3/moGood FriendAccess to short posts and a weekly roundupGratitude
$5/moVery good friendBe able to vote in pollsAccess to monthly in-depth projectAccess to short posts and weekly roundupGratitude
$10/moVery Very Good FriendBe invited to participate in a monthly film club, where we all join in to talk and discuss a film we decide onAccess to notes and research on specific projects. A kind of how-to guide to how specific articles are written. Be able to vote in pollsAccess to monthly in-depth projectAccess to short posts and weekly roundupGratitude
$25/moBest of FriendsAccess to more behind the scenes work, including longer audio files of interviews and more in-depth explainers on how to pitch, how film programming works, etc. I’ll be able to devote a bit of extra time answering your specific questions about whatever you’d like related to my work. Be invited to participate in a monthly film club, where we all join in to talk and discuss a film we decide onAccess to notes and research on specific projects. A kind of how-to guide to how specific articles are written. Be able to vote in pollsAccess to monthly in-depth projectAccess to short posts and weekly roundupETERNAL Gratitude
Growth signals: Justine Smith
0%
Membership2 paid members · 30-day rate from 24 observed days
232
May 202618 weeks trackedNow
Justine Smith2 members · $4/mo
The chart only uses Justine Smith's observed public history. Comparison peers are listed below, but comparable trend series are not available yet.
Where Justine Smith ranks
Creator comparisonsCompare within
#1of 6 measured
Paid members in Recommended cohort
Semantic matches are not ready, so this fixed cohort uses the best available category, audience, pricing, and cadence evidence.
Ranking data · includes stale rows| Rank | Creator and why included | Paid members | Gap vs Justine Smith | Freshness |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 |  Chris FlickWritingCategory, audience, pricing & cadence | 2 | Same value | Aug 25, 2026 |
| #1 |  Juan Pablo UgarteWritingCategory, audience, pricing & cadence | 2 | Same value | Aug 25, 2026 |
| #1 |  Justine SmithProfileWritingPaid members position in Recommended cohort | 2 | Reference | Aug 26, 2026Stale |
| #1 |  Your Favourite Canadian YouTuber, Eh!WritingCategory, audience, pricing & cadence | 2 | Same value | Aug 25, 2026 |
| #6 |  Camp SylvaticaWritingCategory, audience, pricing & cadence | 1 | 1 fewer | Aug 25, 2026 |
The rank uses the full fixed cohort. This table shows up to five creators around Justine Smith; the coverage summary above still counts everyone.
Recent posts
What they publish69Profile posts0 postsLast month91.7%Members-only
Previews available for 25 of 69 posts
Article Latest post$1 tier & upLeaving Criterion to prioritize...Sep 4, 2021
Sep 4, 2021 0 likes 0 commentsThe Big Sleep (1946) Previously unpublishedSep 3, 2021ArticleSep 3, 2021$1 tier & up 0 1What is noir anyway?Sep 2, 2021ArticleSep 2, 2021$1 tier & up 2 2September ThemeAug 25, 2021ArticleAug 25, 2021$1 tier & up 0 0Pedro Costa UnseenAug 17, 2021ArticleAug 17, 2021$1 tier & up 0 0He Ran All The Way (1951)May 10, 2021ArticleMay 10, 2021$1 tier & up 0 0Leaving Criterion Poll April 2021Apr 1, 2021PollApr 1, 2021$1 tier & up 0 0Sinful SundaysMar 30, 2021ArticleMar 30, 2021$1 tier & up 0 0Sinful Sundays: The Magdalene Sisters (Peter Mullan, 2002)Mar 30, 2021ArticleMar 30, 2021Public 0 0Romance (Catherine Breillat, 1999)Mar 25, 2021ArticleMar 25, 2021$1 tier & up 3 2The Slumber Party Massacre (Amy Holden Jones, 1982)No public preview was captured for this post.ImageMar 24, 2021$1 tier & up 0 0Tuesday Shorts (?): Cinéastes de notre temps: Luis BuñuelNo public preview was captured for this post.ArticleMar 23, 2021$1 tier & up 0 0
Research actions
Work with this creator
Save, compare, or return to the Explore view you came from.