Writing
Commentary is Magic
@commentaryismagicTracked since May 2026
creating videos, livestreams, and commentary for the MLPCCG!.
Observed Aug 16, 2026 · staleModeled revenue
Paid members
7
0% · 30-day rate from 13 observed days
Total audience
41
incl. free followers
Estimated monthly gross
$14
$7–$21 modeled range
Starting price
$1/mo
5 membership tiers
Pricing and benefits captured publicly
Membership tiersPatreon is not exposing patron counts by tier for this creator, so this section shows public prices and benefits only.
$0/moFreePublic prices and benefits only
$1/moBackground PonyYou rock, woo-hoo! Patrons at this tier will receive:
Access to Patron-only pollsYour name in thank-you credits at the end of videos, along with our undying gratitude!
$5/moSide CharacterYou're definitely at least 20% cooler! Patrons at this tier will receive:
Access to our Slack general channel, where you can better communicate with CiM members and other PatronsAbility to submit one decklist of your choice, to be featured on a future "Deck Check" video or post!Plus all previous rewards
$10/moThe Great and Powerful PatronNo Alicorn Amulet needed; you're just naturally awesome! Patrons at this tier will receive:
Ability to submit one decklist per month, to be featured on a future "Deck Check" video or post!
Challenge a member of CiM to a game in the format of your choice, up to once per month!
Plus all previous rewards
$25/moMane 6Rarity should be jealous of your generosity! Patrons at this tier will receive:
An invitation to help plan and appear as a special guest for one of our future streams, to focus on a CCG topic of your choice!Early access to custom Villain Challenge cards and rules during the testing processPlus all previous rewards
Growth signals: Commentary is Magic
0%
Membership7 paid members · 30-day rate from 13 observed days
787
May 202617 weeks trackedNow
Commentary is Magic7 members · $14/mo
The chart only uses Commentary is Magic's observed public history. Comparison peers are listed below, but comparable trend series are not available yet.
Where Commentary is Magic ranks
Creator comparisonsCompare within
Not enough data1 of 5 cohort creators measured
30-day member gain in Recommended cohort
Semantic matches are not ready, so this fixed cohort uses the best available category, audience, pricing, and cadence evidence.
Only Commentary is Magic has a comparable public 30-day member gain; at least one measured peer is needed for a cohort rank.Ranking data · includes stale rows| Rank | Creator and why included | 30-day member gain | Gap vs Commentary is Magic | Freshness |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Not ranked |  Commentary is MagicProfileWriting30-day member gain position in Recommended cohort | 0 | Reference | Aug 16, 2026Stale |
| Not ranked |  ClairvoireWritingCategory, audience, pricing & cadence | 30-day comparison unavailable | Not comparable | Aug 26, 2026 |
| Not ranked |  Connie's RAWsome kitchenWritingCategory, audience, pricing & cadence | 30-day comparison unavailable | Not comparable | Aug 16, 2026 |
| Not ranked |  Free Medical EducationWritingCategory, audience, pricing & cadence | 30-day comparison unavailable | Not comparable | Aug 26, 2026 |
| Not ranked |  kimblesWritingCategory, audience, pricing & cadence | 30-day comparison unavailable | Not comparable | Aug 26, 2026 |
The rank uses the full fixed cohort. This table shows up to five creators around Commentary is Magic; the coverage summary above still counts everyone.
Recent posts
What they publish19Profile posts0 postsLast month33.3%Members-only
Previews available for 24 of 19 posts
Poll Latest post$1 tier & upPatron Poll: Cards on loan?Become a Patron now to get access to this and other polls and features!...
Mar 11, 2019 1 vote 2 commentsThanks M. A. Larson!Jun 24, 2018 View post Twilight was before she got wings 17% Twilight was after she got wings 17% Twilight is a good pony regardless of wings 67% Poll ended Jul 8, 2018 · 6 votes totalArticleJun 24, 2018Public 0 0Upcoming Stream ConceptsHey all! We're excited to continue developing weekly content for our Sunday evening streams, but while we take a brief break the weekend of ...ArticleJun 3, 2018$1 tier & up 0 0July's Patron WeekWith convention season well underway, the end of July brings us two of the largest CCG events, BronyCon and Gencon. Specifically, they take the last two weeks, which is when we normally run our Patron Week stream. Since we can't do both a convention and a Patron Week at the same time, we'd like to know how you want the Patron Week to go!ArticleJun 2, 2018Public 0 0First Goal Achieved!What else can we say but "Wow!" We're so grateful to each and every one of our patrons for your support, whether you just joined recently or have been with us from the beginning. As promised, we're planning a special live Q&A stream with plenty of awesome giveaways, so make sure to watch for that announcement in the coming weeks. Until then, thank you for being awesome!ArticleFeb 28, 2018Public 0 0Skystar Chicken?Jan 14, 2018ArticleJan 14, 2018$1 tier & up 0 2Core Constructed Online TournamentsWe're launching a new online tournament series where you'll play against other people from all over the world. If you've ever played over Skype, you're more than equipped to participate.ImageJan 5, 2018Public 0 0Who is best princess?Dec 13, 2017ArticleDec 13, 2017$1 tier & up 1 5First Patron-earned Duel: Blitz!Nov 30, 2017 View post Just in case anyone missed our livestream on Sunday, our Mane 6 Patron Cursedchords earned himself the right to challenge any member (or fellow patron) of CiM to a duel using wacky rules. He elected to challenge Bigcheese to a game of Blitz ponies, where the players are only allowed 10 minutes to build their decks, with additional deckbuilding restrictions being decided on by the players before-hand. Head over to our Youtube channel to watch the duel now and find out who won, or just click the video above!ArticleNov 30, 2017Public 0 0Sealed Pool Building + Tips and Tricks on tonight's stream!Just in time for pre-release next weekend, we'll be discussing what you can do with a limited card pool in order to build the best, most reliable decks possible! Join us tonight at 7 PM Pacific and feel free to ask any questions you may have!ArticleNov 12, 2017Public 0 0CiM Exclusive Spoilers from Nightmare Nights DallasJust in case you missed the video from last Saturday, Commentary is Magic received four exclusive cards to spoil from the upcoming Seaquestria & Beyond set! Check out the video, and make sure to subscribe while you're there!VideoNov 5, 2017Public 0 0Nightmare Duel + Spoiler Discussion VODIf you missed our stream this last Sunday (and the exciting visit from Rob with an unexpected spoiler!), don't worry: it's up on Youtube for you to view at any time! Catch the craziness of combo in a format with no banlist, and listen as we share our thoughts on the first cards revealed for Seaquestria & Beyond.ArticleOct 11, 2017Public 0 0
Research actions
Work with this creator
Save, compare, or return to the Explore view you came from.