Podcasts
When It Was Cool
@wiwcoolTracked since May 2026
creating a Website and Podcast Network.
Observed Aug 15, 2026 · staleModeled revenue
Paid members
Unavailable
growth unavailable
Total audience
Unavailable
not publicly listed
Monthly gross
Unavailable
Starting price
$6/mo
7 membership tiers
Pricing and benefits captured publicly
Membership tiersPatreon is not exposing patron counts by tier for this creator, so this section shows public prices and benefits only.
$0/moFreePublic prices and benefits only
$6/moPatreon Package 1 (Lowest Price)OUR MOST POPULAR LEVEL!You Get:All of our free showsNumerous special paid only shows per monthAccess to most of the When It Was Cool back catalog of showsSuper Power 1: You can suggest one show topic per month for any of Karl or Tonya's podcasts (When It Was Cool Retro, Dark, or Wrestling or a special Patreon only show)
$11/moPatreon Package 2 (+ PDFs books)You Get:All of our free showsNumerous special paid only shows per monthAccess to most of the When It Was Cool back catalog of showsSuper Power 1: You can suggest one show topic per month for any of Karl or Tonya's podcasts (When It Was Cool Retro, Dark, or Wrestling or a special Patreon only show)Includes .pdf copies of DragonKingKarl's Pro Wrestling Omnibus Books
$26/moPatreon Package 3 (Booster!)You Get:All of our free showsNumerous special paid only shows per month (including the High Roller Podcast Special)Access to all of the When It Was Cool back catalog of showsSuper Power 1: You can suggest two show topics per month for any of Karl or Tonya's podcasts (When It Was Cool Retro, Dark, or Wrestling or a special Patreon only show)Includes PDFs of DragonKingKarl's Pro Wrestling Omnibus BooksYou will be created as one of our top tier boosters. Thank you!
$50/moPatreon Package 4 (Super Booster!)You Get:All of our free showsNumerous special paid only shows per month.Access to all of the When It Was Cool back catalog of showsSuper Power 1: You can suggest three show topics per month for any of Karl or Tonya's podcasts (When It Was Cool Retro, Dark, or Wrestling or a special Patreon only show)Includes PDFs of DragonKingKarl Stern's Pro Wrestling Omnibus BooksYou will be created as one of our Super Boosters! Thank you!
$100/moPatreon Package 5 (Mega Booster!)$43
$200/moPatreon Package 6 (Angel Investor)$44
Growth signals: When It Was Cool
Not measurable
MembershipLast observed 2026-08-15. Not enough recent observation yet for a 30-day reading.
010
May 202618 weeks trackedNow
When It Was Coolmembers unavailable · revenue unavailable
The chart only uses When It Was Cool's observed public history. Comparison peers are listed below, but comparable trend series are not available yet.
Where When It Was Cool ranks
Creator comparisonsCompare within
Not enough data0 of 5 cohort creators measured
Paid members in Recommended cohort
Semantic matches are not ready, so this fixed cohort uses the best available category, audience, pricing, and cadence evidence.
When It Was Cool does not yet have a measured paid-member count. 0 of 5 cohort creators are measured for this metric.Ranking data · includes stale rows| Rank | Creator and why included | Paid members | Gap vs When It Was Cool | Freshness |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Not ranked |  When It Was CoolProfilePodcastsPaid members position in Recommended cohort | Not measured | Reference | Aug 15, 2026Stale |
| Not ranked |  The Working Actor's JourneyPodcastsCategory, audience, pricing & cadence | Not measured | Not comparable | Aug 26, 2026 |
| Not ranked |  Will to Joy - Nietzsche for LifePodcastsCategory, audience, pricing & cadence | Not measured | Not comparable | Aug 15, 2026Stale |
| Not ranked |  William Ramsey InvestigatesPodcastsCategory, audience, pricing & cadence | Not measured | Not comparable | Aug 25, 2026 |
| Not ranked |  Wine About ItPodcastsCategory, audience, pricing & cadence | Not measured | Not comparable | Aug 25, 2026 |
The rank uses the full fixed cohort. This table shows up to five creators around When It Was Cool; the coverage summary above still counts everyone.
Recent posts
What they publish140Posts total4 postsLast month83.3%Members-only
Previews available for 140 posts
Audio Latest postPublicLong Form History of Wrestling Podcast - September 1986 (Chris Adams, New WWF TV Shows, More!)
1:09:28 Long Form History of Wrestling Podcast - September 1986 (Chris Adams, New WWF TV Shows, More!) Long Form History of Wrestling Podcast - September 1986 (Chris Adams, New WWF TV Shows, More!) 7 hours ago 3
7 hours ago 0 likes 0 commentsLong Form History of Wrestling Podcast - August 1986 - Ric Flair Wins NWA Title, Bama Bash, and GIANT Patreon Over Run About Wrestling Observer Website RumorsLocked Long Form History of Wrestling Podcast - August 1986 - Ric Flair Wins NWA Title, Bama Bash, and GIANT Patreon Over Run About Wrestling Observer Website Rumors July 14 10 25AudioJuly 14$6 tier & up 10 25
Happy Days Retro TV Review (New!)Locked Happy Days Retro TV Review (New!) August 6 8 19 1:12:45AudioAugust 6$6 tier & up 8 19
DragonKingKarl Classic Wrestling Podcast - Big John Somebody and His IROC-ZToday's DragonKingKarl Show is only being distributed through the When It Was Cool Podcast Network. After speaking with Wrestling Observer/FAudioJuly 28Public 12 14DragonKingKarl Classic Wrestling Podcast - The History of the NWA World Title Part 1 - Special Patreon Section on Is the Wrestling Observer Website Failing or DyingLocked DragonKingKarl Classic Wrestling Podcast - The History of the NWA World Title Part 1 - Special Patreon Section on Is the Wrestling Observer Website Failing or Dying July 21 11 12ImageJuly 21$6 tier & up 11 12
Andy Griffith Show Revisited (NEW!) PodcastLocked Andy Griffith Show Revisited (NEW!) Podcast August 13 6 6ArticleAugust 13$6 tier & up 6 6
103 1000 Hours Podcast - William Muldoon Whips John L. Sullivan Into ShapeLocked 103 1000 Hours Podcast - William Muldoon Whips John L. Sullivan Into Shape August 9 8 4ArticleAugust 9$6 tier & up 8 4
Happy American Independence Day!Locked Happy American Independence Day! July 4 14 3ArticleJuly 4$6 tier & up 14 3
Fireside Chat with Karl and Tonya - Cat Shaving and Other MattersLocked Fireside Chat with Karl and Tonya - Cat Shaving and Other Matters July 16 9 6ArticleJuly 16$6 tier & up 9 6
DragonKingKarl Classic Wrestling Podcast - 1986 Pro Wrestling Illustrated Year End AwardsLocked DragonKingKarl Classic Wrestling Podcast - 1986 Pro Wrestling Illustrated Year End Awards June 9 11 10ArticleJune 9$6 tier & up 11 10
Woe Unto Thee Brightspeed. Show Delay Announcement10 Woe Unto Thee Brightspeed. Show Delay Announcement Locked Woe Unto Thee Brightspeed. Show Delay Announcement August 14 6 5ArticleAugust 14$6 tier & up 6 5
May QUESTION & ANSWER Show Thread - Post Questions Here!5 May QUESTION & ANSWER Show Thread - Post Questions Here! Locked May QUESTION & ANSWER Show Thread - Post Questions Here! May 3 7 21AudioMay 3$6 tier & up 7 21
Research actions
Work with this creator
Save, compare, or return to the Explore view you came from.